Old Fitzgerald 11YR Review

Hannah’s Old Fitzgerald 11YR Review

Original review written March 1, 2022

GENERAL DESCRIPTION:

It’s good, light, and easy to sip. Is it worth $100+ though? Doubtful. I’m enjoying it, but I won’t feel incredibly pressured to repurchase once it’s gone. 86/100

VITALS:
Old Fitzgerald 11YR Review

– Made In: Louisville, Kentucky, USA
– Distiller: Bernheim Distillery/DSP-KY-1
– Classification: Bottled in Bond Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
– Age: 11 yrs.
– Mash Bill: Corn=68%; Wheat=20%; Malted Barley=12%
– Casks: Char #3
– Barrel Entry Proof: 125
– ABV: 50% (100 proof)
– Price: $109.95 USD in Idaho 2022

Visit heavenhilldistillery.com for more information

ENJOYMENT METHOD:

I enjoyed the spirit neat from a Glencairn glass with father and fellow Whiskey for the Ages reviewer, Brian.

Check out his review for this bourbon here!

SETTING:

This would be a good bourbon to have on the shores of a small pond. Petals have fallen and sweetened the water, and their color shines out bright and obvious in some warm sunlight. They are soft to hold, and the water is warm enough to have your feet settled in. It’s healing in its own way, and certainly quite relaxing with gentle smells playing on a breeze.

Photo by Travis Grossen on Unsplash

NOSE:

This isn’t as aromatic as I was expecting it to be. I find peppery notes, along with a fresh, herbally quality. I can’t identify much for fruit aside from maybe some green apples. However, there is a simple syrup, yellow cake, and a floral element and maybe a sprinkle of some cinnamon if I squint. I wish there were more aromas to note, but this really is just very simple and gentle. It smells good, certainly, but I can’t help but feel… slightly let down by this nose? Not much for wood or even an alcohol burn.

PALATE:
Old Fitzgerald 11YR Review

– Mouth Feel: This starts raspy across the palate, but at the back of the sip, it surprisingly turns almost watery. It’s a confusing aspect of this bourbon.
– Balance: Solid balance. While simple, everything is still quite well-blended and I have no complaints.
– Visual: Auburn in color, this leaves behind an irregular crown and many long, lingering legs down the side of the glass.

– Taste: The taste is a definite improvement from the nose, with the mouth feel kicking in with a raspy quality and coaxing out more fruit and even more floral essences. It’s rosy, and stone fruit comes into play a lot more here as well, particularly light stone fruit. The end of the sip offers up some cherries, grapes, and light oak, which adds some necessary complexity to this bourbon. There’s some light caramel, and more light spices like cinnamon.

All in all, this is very easy to sip, and the alcohol is remarkably gentle. I could see getting in trouble with this bourbon. It’s entertaining, and a Kentucky chew makes the sugary flavors stand out that much more.

I will say, that if I was looking to pour something light and fresh, I might sooner go to a rye for a cheaper price than a bourbon that is valued at over $100 USD.

FINISH:

– Lasting Power: Medium. There is some residual warmth that builds up throughout the course of the glass, and some minor aftertaste.
– Between Sips: Rose and grape linger between sips, but they don’t stick around for long. Nevertheless, it’s still quite enjoyable.

– No More: This stays consistent throughout the glass, and I think it does grow on you considerably – especially if you’re a fan of dark, charred oak, rich bourbons. It does grow on you.

The empty Glencairn is a warmer, richer oak with fruit buried within. It’s different from other empty glasses, and it’s something I could picture being a candle quite easily.

WORTH THE PRICE?

Simply put, no. $100+ is a big ask, and this just is not worth that price. I’d pay $40 comfortably, or even $50, but $100 is just not an appropriate amount to me for this bourbon. I already know it’s a bourbon I’ll have to be in the mood for, in order to pour, and I don’t know if I’ll be in the mood often. It won’t be a bourbon I’ll hate finishing, but it does sting to know we paid this much for it, to be entirely honest.

OLD FITZGERALD 11YR REVIEW RATING: 86/100

Click to see Hannah’s rating process

Click 86/100 to access other whiskies with this rating.

Back to …

Hannah’s Whiskey Reviews
Whiskey Reviews

Booker’s 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch Bourbon

Brian’s Booker’s 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch Bourbon:

reviewed 22-February-2022

BOOKER’S 2021-04 NOE STRANGERS BATCH BOURBON REVIEW:

For me, Booker’s 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch (Booker’s 2021-04) is the most “un-Bookerish” release I have ever enjoyed. And enjoy is not a strong enough accolade. It may even be the best batch since my first, Booker’s 2018-01 Kathleen’s Batch, and all of the others since. Its aromas are fruity, and the flavors are full of jammy heat. The signature Booker’s nuttiness is more sensed than tasted or smelled. This bourbon would be just as good with a PB&J sandwich as it would with a slow-smoked brisket. There is no need to add water. It lessens both aromas and flavors and shortens the finish. I only wish I had several backup bottles in the bunker as I have a feeling this one is not going to last.

BOOKER’S 2021-04 NOE STRANGERS BATCH VITAL STATS:
Booker's 2021-04 Noe Strangers

Category: Small Batch Bourbon
Region: Clermont, Kentucky, USA
Distiller: Jim Beam, Master Distiller Fred Noe
Small Batch: 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch
Mash bill: 77% Corn, 13% Rye, 10% Malted Barley
Casks: New Charred Oak
Barrel Char: #4
Barrel Entry Proof: 125
Age: 6 Years 6 Months 12 Days
ABV: 62.2% (124.4 Proof)
NABCA CSC #: 16906
Price: $89.95 (Idaho, Dec 2021)
Availability: Allocated, limited, released quarterly/tri-anually

MASTER DISTILLER NOTES:

Noe Strangers batch comes from four production dates, with barrels aged in four different warehouses as follows:

39% came from the 6th floor of 9-story warehouse J
31% came from the 5th floor of 7-story warehouse Q
27% came from the 5th floor of 9-story warehouse D
3% came from the 2nd floor of 9-story warehouse H

LABEL INSPIRATION
Booker's 2021-04 Noe Strangers

The fourth release of the Booker’s® Bourbon 2021 Collection is Booker’s Batch 2021-04 ‘Noe Strangers Batch.’ This batch celebrates the genuine, social nature of my dad, Booker Noe, and the way he could turn a stranger into a friend for life in no time.

Take for example when Dad took a liking to the products that a salesman was selling. He would call out to Mom and say, “Set an extra plate at the table, I’m inviting this salesman to dinner!” Another time, Dad was invited to a rally for the Blue Knights® Motorcycle Club, an international brotherhood of active and retired law enforcement officers who share a passion for motorcycle riding. There he struck up a conversation with some of the members, and the next day, more than 300 of them were invited to the house for lunch.

His knack for making friends carried into his work as well. Here in Kentucky and out on the road, Dad wouldn’t leave a bourbon event until he shook hands with everyone that wanted to talk to him. He’d listen to stories from every customer he met and just like that, they’d become a fan – and a friend – for life. Dad taught us to ‘treat others how we would want to be treated’– a lesson our family holds true to this day. It’s just the way us Noes are wired.

As you enjoy “Noe Strangers Batch,” I hope you’ll think of Dad and his generous way of making everyone he met feel at home. Like we always say at the distillery: come as friends, leave as family.

— Fred Noe, Beam Family 7th Generation Master Distiller

Learn more at Booker’s Bourbon.

ENJOYMENT METHOD FOR THE REVIEW:

Taken out of the newly opened bottle, the first one and a half ounces mixed with the bourbon in our Infinity Bottle Project. Then, by alternating pours, four once review amounts went into two Glencairns. My daughter and I enjoyed the bourbon neat for this review.

Check out her review for this bourbon here!

BOOKER’S 2021-04 NOE STRANGERS BATCH NOSE:

The first wafts of Booker’s 2021-04 caught me off guard, but pleasantly so. The pour is unlike a typical Booker’s … It smells juicy, like a fruity oak aged Chardonnay, but deeper and darker. With further nosing I detect dark dried currants, and both black and blueberries with some fresh apple butter sprinkled with allspice, white pepper and rye. The aromas are sweet, like rich vanilla infused yellow cake with a light brown sugar and toffee frosting. And while I get nuts, they are more of sensation than anything specific. And when I bring the Glencairn to my mouth, I smell the toasted wood of sweet light oak BBQ smoke.

BOOKER’S 2021-04 NOE STRANGERS BATCH PALATE:

Booker’s 2021-04 has the characteristic warming high proof bourbon burn I get in most Booker’s releases. But while I do taste the typical subtle roasted corn, this one is usually jammy and full of dark berry nectar with flavors of ripe currants and fresh raisins. For me, this is the most fruit forward Booker’s I can remember – think dark berry jam with heat. Along with fruitiness, I taste cinnamon, ginger, and black pepper balanced by rich vanilla, burnt brown sugar caramel and hints of maple syrup. The sweet flavors are savory and remind me of a hearty homemade BBQ sauce. While I don’t get the typical Booker’s peanuts, I do want to sit and enjoy this with a jar of peanut butter as its seasoned oak blends with hazy toasted wood and sweet BBQ smoke.

Booker's 2021-04 Noe Strangers

Balance, Body, Feel and Look:
Booker’s 2021-04 is solid and well blended. It does give the tongue and mouth an aggressive tickle, but once the taste buds acclimate, the liquid becomes quite creamy. As I peer into the glass after each sip, the liquid curtain breaks into widely spaced, long drops which return the dregs to the mahogany colored pool leaving behind a thin ring.

BOOKER’S 2021-04 NOE STRANGERS BATCH FINISH:

Booker’s 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch has an exceptionally long almost hot finish of the memory of dark berry jam and fresh raisin nectar. I also sense black pepper, rich vanilla and the essence of nearly burnt BBQ sauce. This finish is all Booker’s as seasoned oak marries with smoky sweet BBQ sauce. And when gone, the empty Glencairn smells like sweet oak sawdust infused with molasses.


Water can often tame big, bold whiskeys and allow aromas and flavors to bloom. The addition of 2-4 drops will not radically lower the proof of the pour. Re-evaluation of Booker’s 2021-04 occurred several days after the first assessment using measured pours and precise amounts of distilled water to detail its effect.

THE ADDITION OF TWO DROPS OF WATER

Adding two drops to 1.5 ounces of this bourbon reduces the proof to 124.04 (down from 124.4). It still smells juicy, deep and dark with notes of dark dried currants, apple butter and allspice. I also smell rich vanilla and light brown sugar frosting mixed with toasted wood sweet BBQ smoke but other aromas noted above are greatly muted. When sipped, I get warm high proof bourbon with a little roasted corn but like I mentioned above, 2021-04 remains a dark currant and fresh raisin jam with heat. Spices of cinnamon, ginger, and black pepper continue to be balanced with rich vanilla and brown sugar caramel. These flavors are savory and I taste a few peanuts in seasoned oak which blend quickly into hazy toasted wood and sweet smoke. While still good, two drops of water diminish both aromas and flavors and in my opinion, are not needed.

THE ADDITION OF FOUR DROPS OF WATER

Adding four drops to 1.5 ounces of bourbon lowers the proof to 123.68 (a 0.58% reduction from the bottling). Most surprising, I now get alcohol in each nosing. While dark dried currants and apple butter with allspice and pepper still come through, the aromas are less fruit sweet and the vanilla and light brown sugar take center stage. I still get the characteristic Booker’s warmth in each taste, as well as a bit of roasted corn, but the currants and raisins with cinnamon, ginger, are washed out. The vanilla and brown sugar caramel with some seasoned oak and hazy toasted wood remain savory, but the finish shortens. Four drops of distilled water are too much for Noe Strangers.

MY RATING: 94/100;
… with two drops 90/100;
… with four drops 89/100

Will I buy this whiskey again? YES
I will always purchase Booker’s batches when bottles are found at retail on store shelves.
Click to read Brian’s scoring process.

Click 94/100 to access other whiskeys with this score.
To access other whiskies from this brand, click Booker’s.

WHISKEY TRAITS, FLAVOR NOTES AND PROFILE GRAPH:
Booker's 2021-04 Noe Strangers
Booker's 2021-04 Noe Strangers

Back to …

Brian’s Whiskey Reviews
Individual Whiskey Reviews

Booker’s 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch Review

Hannah’s Booker’s 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch Review

Original review written February 22, 2022

GENERAL DESCRIPTION:

One of the best Booker’s batches I’ve had in a while, this one has everything you could possibly want out of a bourbon from mouth feel to balance. Just perfectly enjoyable. 95/100

VITALS:
Booker's 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch Review

– Made In: Clermont, Kentucky, USA
– Distiller: Jim Beam Distillery
– Classification: Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey; Small Batch
– Age: 6 yrs., 6 mo., 12 days
– Mash Bill: Corn=77%; Rye=13%; Malted Barley=10%
– Casks: Char #4
– Barrel Entry Proof: 125
– ABV: 62.2% (124.4 proof)
– Price: $89.95 USD in Idaho (2021)

Booker's 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch Review

– From Master Distiller’s Notes: Noe Strangers Batch is made up of barrels that were aged in 4 different locations/warehouses (WH)… Breakdown is as follows:
39%: 6th floor of 9-story WH J
31%: 5th floor of 7-story WH Q
27%: 5th floor of 9-story WH D
3%: 2nd floor of 9-story WH H

Find more information at bookersbourbon.com

ENJOYMENT METHOD:

I enjoyed the spirit neat from a Glencairn glass with father and fellow Whiskey for the Ages reviewer, Brian.

Check out his review for this bourbon here!

SETTING:

This bourbon screams comfort, with warmth and peace. I imagine sipping Noe Strangers Batch while eating some gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches. Oozy cheese, crunchy toast, maybe with some fancy dips. The point is, is that it’s familiar, yet new, making it both safe and exciting all at once.

Photo by Pixzolo Photography on Unsplash

NOSE:

Caramel, vanilla, chocolate, and cake waft from the glass on the first inhale, followed by the traditional Booker’s spice of black pepper, cinnamon and nutmeg. There’s dusty grain on deep draws that pairs with a salty savory-ness, almost like barbeque. It’s even coupled with the smoky quality you would associate with grilling. In fact, I think these flavors take over a bit the longer I sit and nose this bourbon. There’s some fruit, perhaps assorted berries, but I don’t think these are the main heroes among these aromas. I wouldn’t say there are many flavors beyond those mentioned, but the flavors are very intense and deep, making it already enjoyable.

PALATE:
Booker's 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch Review

– Mouth Feel: Syrupy. I absolutely love the feeling of this one and think it matches the personality of this bourbon well.
– Balance: Sweet heavy, but the backend of heat makes it all very well-balanced.
– Visual: Mahogany in color, this falls in sheets, leaving only droplets behind and the occasional thin leg.

– Taste: I was expecting significantly more heat on this palate than what I actually received. Fruits come to life in both a dried and ripened sense. I get the berries from the nose as well as dried apples. A sprinkling of cinnamon comes across the back end, highlighting the fruit and giving the bourbon a bit of a kick too, which I appreciate. There is simple syrup, vanilla, and more cake too, making this bourbon so pleasantly sweet. Nevertheless, the proof is there, making the whole sip warm and the slightest bit aggressive.

The alcohol doesn’t seem affronting during the sip, but the kick that comes afterwards has the full potential to burn and fight back. A Kentucky chew surprisingly is not too painful, and it awakens a pastry and raspberry element, like a Danish pastry, and I am simply put, in love.

FINISH:

– Lasting Power: Very long. The heat lingers and lingers and lingers with minor aftertaste, but it is still enjoyable.
– Between Sips: Dusty grain lingers between sips with plenty of alcohol warmth, along with light caramel and raspberries.

– No More: Stays consistent throughout the glass with the mouth feel becoming more and more enjoyable as I go.

The empty Glencairn has sweet sawdust at the bottom, and it is lovely. But now I just want another glass.

THE ADDITION OF WATER

– This section written on February 26, 2022 –

Booker's 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch Review

Booker’s 2021-04 Noe Strangers Batch Review: Water can often tame bold whiskeys and the addition of 2-4 drops will not radically change the proof of the pour. Rather water may help open the spirit allowing the aromas and flavors to bloom. As such, 2 and 4 drops of distilled water were added to their own respective 1.5 oz. pours of Booker’s Noe Strangers Batch to detect any potential differences:

Two drops of water make for a toasty bread nose with a jammy element, like strawberries and blackberries. The palate initially starts with considerably more wood than what was found on the neat pour. Dark fruits follow the wood, along with sweet mano dusted with chili powder (it’s quite a good candy – don’t knock it till you try it). There is still significant heat to this, despite being watered down. It feels less likely to hug, but it does still rasp at the throat. The syrupy feel isn’t as potent now, though I do enjoy this mouth feel. (RATING: 94/100)

Caramel comes out on the nose right away with four drops of water. I don’t even wait to take a sip, and am now greeted with not just caramel, but apples also. There’s a wood chip quality, making the balance chewy and thick. I think a lot of the original complexity has been stripped here with this much water. While fruit is still present, it’s quite subdued, and it shows up more on the finish than on the direct palate. The alcohol is even more gentle, which is expected, but the warmth also takes a bit of a hit as a result. This is fine, but I wouldn’t recommend more than two drops of water four this bourbon. (RATING: 88/100)

WORTH THE PRICE?

Yes, yes, yes, and yes. This is one of the best Booker’s batches I’ve had in a while. The mouth feel, the balance of sweet to alcoholic kick – this is what bourbon is all about. If you find it, give it a try.

BOOKER’S 2021-04 NOE STRANGERS BATCH REVIEW RATING: 95/100

Click to see Hannah’s rating process

Click 95/100 to access other whiskies with this rating.
To access other whiskies from this brand, click Booker’s.

Back to…

Hannah’s Whiskey Reviews
Whiskey Reviews